I recently found a great set of videos by the Royal Society of Arts (RSA). The RSA is a UK institute with a long, impressive history. As far as I can tell, its main purpose is collaborating efforts in social research, policy development and effecting real, positive social change. Not just a think-tank.
The RSA videos are very engaging, especially a group under the banner of RSA Animate. Instead of watching a person for 10 minutes, you are drawn into the content through a cartoon developed in parallel with the talk.
The one below is a presentation by Barbara Ehrenreich, author of “Nickel and Dimed”. It’s about unrealistic positivity (“keeping up appearances” in my parlance).
Much of the video is about the corporate workplace, where expressing pessimism can be a death knell. I know this from personal experience. My corporate career swung up and down in line with my moods. A long spell of unbridled, hypomanic optimism saw me climb the ladder with frightening speed. When the crash came I was immediately out of step with corporate culture and my shelf life was curtailed. Then new job, rinse and repeat.
To my way of thinking, reciting affirmations is a close cousin to unrealistic, unquestioning optimism. Barbara Ehrenreich touches on this in the video. I’ve tried affirmations many times, and given up just as many. Do affirmations change your world?
Depressed folk like me gravitate to the self-help section of Amazon. There is no shortage of advice on the power of positivity. As much as I wish I was a magnet for happiness, my life is more complicated and just thinking it so won’t make it so. That is why this video resonates with me.
If you can’t see the player then watch the video on YouTube. To watch more of the RSA Animate videos visit the RSA blog.



Joylene 29 Aug 2008 @ 2:52 pm
great post!! so true!
Christina 29 Aug 2008 @ 4:51 pm
Thank you for posting this. I’m considering printing out several copies and “accidentally” leave them lying around.
Shannon 30 Aug 2008 @ 2:10 pm
Nice post. When I have been unable to do things because of depression and anxiety people would sometimes say things like, “Sometimes we have to make ourselves do things.”
Or, “Stop using it as a crutch.”
My crutch is invisible and I need it.
I don’t mind labeling myself “depressed”, “anxious”.
The fact of the matter is, ignoring that I have a problem will not make it go away nor somehow make me better.
John D 4 Sep 2008 @ 12:00 am
There are some harrowing quotes there – so hard to believe people saying things like that. Of course, I’ve had to listen to many similar, including the classic Get a life! in a recent blog comment. I’ve read many exchanges among blog commenters about depression, and I’m struck by how angry people can get while insisting that depression is a choice or something you could wish away if you had some serious willpower . I wonder where the intensity of their feeling comes from. Why are some so intent on denying a reality that many suffer from? It’s a subject that needs more exploration. Thank you for this fine post.